READ
Verified Evidence Index
Source-first map of the current evidence set.
INVESTIGATIVE REPORT
CAD / DISPATCH
911 / PRIVACY REVIEW
VIDEO / BODYCAM
COMMAND REVIEW
STATE OVERSIGHT
HB 87
DA REFERRAL
RECEIPTS
Evidence Library
DON’T TAKE OUR WORD FOR IT.
The public library includes privacy-redacted records, agency-redacted Benally video segments, WatchGuard audit material, DA records, IPRA correspondence, command-review records, the DPS response, HB 87 correspondence, timestamp aids, and provenance files.
Privacy first: identifying information about the female passenger and bus driver is removed. Unreviewed audio and complete-playback files are withheld until names, voices, and non-official faces are privacy-safe.
START WITH THE VERIFIED INDEX
PRIMARY / SOURCE RECORDS
READ
MCSO Investigative Report
Privacy-redacted public copy of the MCSO PDF attachment received August 14, 2026.
WATCH
Bittony Bodycam
Complete playback copy is externally linked. Timestamp guide and transcript are embedded here.
READ / LISTEN
CAD + 911 / Dispatch
Original CAD, preserved dispatch archive, extracted WAV, and CDR track export.
WATCH
Benally Recordings + Audit
Two MCSO-produced recordings and the WatchGuard audit log.
READ / LISTEN
DA Referral + Status
Produced review/log record, chronology reproduction, and the recorded DA call.
READ
IPRA / Records History
Fifteen-exhibit correspondence compilation documenting the records trail.
ORIGINAL AUDIO
THE 911 / DISPATCH RECORD HAS A VOICE.
The site includes the extracted 911/dispatch WAV and the CDR track export from the preserved dispatch archive.
LISTEN IN CONTEXT →COMMAND / STATE / LEGISLATIVE RECORDS
READ
Maiorano Command Review
August 21 reproduction of the command-review statement.
READ
DPS State Oversight Response
August 24 response concerning the absence of an appellate state review venue for this type of challenge.
READ
HB 87 Legislative Responses
August 24 responses from Rep. Dayan Hochman-Vigil and Sen. Peter Wirth.
EVIDENCE TOPICS
Language / Translator
Translator request, limited-English statements, and documented comprehension problems.
OPEN →Six “Touching” Moments
Full timestamp block, followed by the first buttocks-specific formulation at 28:31.
OPEN →Ten Alternative Explanations
Full timestamped block showing what was supplied, reinforced, reintroduced, rejected, or unsupported.
OPEN →Nine Reassurances
Full timestamped sequence, including the five-second 34:47 → 34:52 contrast.
OPEN →Money / Fraud Discussion
Financial-motive speculation and the insurance-fraud analogy.
OPEN →Report vs. Bodycam
What the recording preserved versus what the written narrative says.
OPEN →THE RECEIPTS: 6 / 10 / 9
When these counts are used on this site, the timestamped record stays with them.
6 TIMES THE ALLEGATION BECAME JUST “TOUCHING”
Bittony already knew the female passenger had reported multiple instances of touching of her butt and private area.
28:31 — “But the girl was saying that he was touching her butt.”
This is the first identified buttocks-specific description. The full allegation involving both her butt and private area still is not clearly presented to Shubham on the available recording.
This is the first identified buttocks-specific description. The full allegation involving both her butt and private area still is not clearly presented to Shubham on the available recording.
10 INNOCENT-EXPLANATION MOMENTS
WHY IT MATTERS
The issue is not that an investigator considered innocent possibilities. It is who supplied those possibilities, when they were supplied, and what happened when Shubham rejected or failed to support them.
The issue is not that an investigator considered innocent possibilities. It is who supplied those possibilities, when they were supplied, and what happened when Shubham rejected or failed to support them.
9 REASSURANCES
FIVE SECONDS APART
34:47 — “You’re not going to go to jail.”
34:52 — “I have to gather all the evidence to put it together into a report.”
34:47 — “You’re not going to go to jail.”
34:52 — “I have to gather all the evidence to put it together into a report.”