Skip to main content
EVERY REGISTERED McKINLEY COUNTY VOTER CAN VOTE BY MAIL.
Request mail ballot
Early votingstarts in days
Election Dayis in days
Emergency Exit
IF VICTIMS DESERVE BETTER THE RECORD · THE QUESTIONS · THE TRUTH

Site policies · Privacy · Sources

SITE POLICIES.

How this independent site handles privacy, evidence, comments, corrections, and replies.

SITE POLICIES

Privacy, evidence standards, corrections, and replies for If Victims Deserve Better.

SITE POLICY

Visitor counter + public log

The current public count began September 1, 2026; earlier test, automated, and uncertain rows are excluded. The counter assigns one cookie to each browser and filters obvious automated requests. New browsers are counted only after returning that cookie; browsers that block it are not added on every refresh. “Visiting now” is the approximate number of counted browsers seen during the last five minutes; it is not a count of individual people. “U.S. states reached” keeps a cumulative record of distinct U.S. states, excluding Washington, D.C. A later location update does not remove a previously recorded state. The visitor log preserves recorded approximate locations, including earlier places when a browser’s location changes. A browser counts once per location and once in the site total, so location counts should not be added together. Available city records and later location updates are preserved; older overwritten city records cannot be reconstructed from state-only history. “Countries reached” preserves distinct recorded country codes, including visitors who are not in a U.S. state. “Last visit” shows the most recent different counted browser with a usable approximate location, not the current visitor.

To supply an approximate location, the visitor’s current IP address is sent to IPWho.is. For U.S. visits, the approximate coordinates returned by IPWho.is may be sent to the U.S. Census Geocoder to determine the official metropolitan statistical area. This site stores the returned city, state, country, and Census metro code. It does not store the IP address or coordinates. The public visitor log groups browsers by approximate place and never displays a visitor ID, cookie value, IP address, coordinates, or metro code. Locations may be inaccurate when someone uses a VPN, mobile network, workplace network, or shared connection.

OPEN THE PUBLIC VISITOR LOG →

To limit repeated form submissions, the site uses request counters keyed by a daily rotating, hashed network identifier. Raw IP addresses are not saved in those counters, and the counters are not linked to visitor history or submitted messages. Expired counters are cleared when another submission arrives.

SITE POLICY

Private reader-activity totals

The site keeps daily aggregate counts of evidence-link opens, recording-link opens, native audio/video starts, flyer and graphic clicks, and copied section links. These totals are visible only to the site owner and are kept for up to 90 days. They contain public page paths and approved destinations, with no visitor IDs, IP addresses, location data, referrers, URL queries, or search terms. They are not connected to the visitor log. Do Not Track and Global Privacy Control are respected. Actions are not counts of unique people or proof of completed downloads. Playback inside Google Drive cannot be confirmed by this site.

SITE POLICY

Evidence integrity

Records, recordings, quotations, and timestamps are presented for public review. Web copies may be compressed or privacy-redacted, but the site does not alter what a source says or depicts. The original agency record remains the controlling source.

OPEN THE EVIDENCE LIBRARY →

SITE POLICY

AI assistance

AI assistance has been used to organize records, compare documents, draft site text, and build this site. It has also assisted with preparing public copies, including privacy redactions, document reproductions, and web playback formats. Those changes are described in the source notes; the original records and recordings remain the sources for what occurred.

SITE POLICY

Comments, guestbook + moderation

No account is required. A commenter may use a name, pseudonym, or post anonymously. Comments are reviewed before publication. Criticism and disagreement are allowed; threats, doxxing, impersonation, spam, private contact information, and unsupported factual accusations are not.

Optional comment email addresses are not published. Automatic comment response alerts are not currently offered. The guestbook does not ask for an email address. Guestbook names or nicknames, optional locations, and messages are published after review; these voluntary entries are separate from the automatic visitor log.

SITE POLICY

Methodology + attribution

The site separates documented facts, allegations, questions, and unknowns. It distinguishes what the female passenger reported, what the driver reported, what Shubham said, what Bittony suggested, what a civilian supplied, and what the written report attributes to each person.

READ THE METHODOLOGY →

SITE POLICY

Corrections

Substantive corrections are logged publicly. New records may clarify or change how a point is described; the site should update the presentation without hiding the correction.

OPEN CORRECTIONS →

SITE POLICY

Right of reply

Named officials, agencies, and other people discussed by the project may provide a response. Responses may be published in full or linked, subject to ordinary safety, privacy, and formatting limits.

READ THE RIGHT-OF-REPLY POLICY →

SITE POLICY

Victim and witness privacy

Victim and witness names, residential addresses, personal phone numbers, personal email addresses, and other private identifiers are removed from public copies of documents, recordings, and correspondence.

Public-record information is labeled as recorded information when independent verification is not documented.

SITE POLICY

Voting information

Voting links point to official New Mexico election resources. This is an independent project and is not affiliated with MCSO, McKinley County, or any political campaign. Visitors should rely on the linked official source for current deadlines and eligibility.

OPEN THE OFFICIAL MAIL-IN BALLOT APPLICATION →

SOURCE NOTES

Public source files and notes explaining how records are presented on this site.

SOURCE NOTES

Verified Evidence Index

Current public records, recordings, and source guides, with direct links.

OPEN THE INDEX →

SOURCE NOTES

Dispatch recording index

Track order, channels, start times and durations for the dispatch, phone and radio recordings. Contact and system identifiers are removed from the public copy.

OPEN THE RECORDING INDEX →

SOURCE NOTES

Shubham: police record and photograph notes

The Shubham page presents entries from the police record, details visible in the produced recordings, and statements on bodycam. The available record does not document independent verification of the mononym entry, date of birth, address, phone number, citizenship, or immigration status. The phone number recorded for Shubham was reportedly disconnected, and the Fayetteville address omitted an apartment or unit number. The available record does not show how deputies verified reliable contact and locating information before he left Gallup.

Citizenship and immigration status are unknown. Saying that Shubham was from India does not establish citizenship or immigration status.

The user-provided photographs on the Shubham page show the number 167 and two separate front entrances. MCSO’s recorded address does not include a unit designation.

SEE THE SOURCE → WHAT CAN I DO? →